Because Hawaii is a place of such diverse cultures, it became inevitable that elements of these cultures would overlap – particularly in the food. Because of it, quite a few new dishes have been created, so, if you are ever in Hawaii, you should be sure to try them. Without further ado, here is a Hawaii food bucket list (from a local).
Everyone makes fun of Hawaii locals for eating Spam. Well wait until you try it in musubi form. A musubi is traditionally a spam and rice roll wrapped in seaweed, but recently I’ve seen other items added to it, like egg, avocado, and even smoked eel. While locals prefer to get their musubis from 7/11, you can also get some from the nearby ABC stores.
Fun fact: Spam is actually made in Minnesota.
Passion Orange Guava Juice. It’s delicious. You can find it at almost any grocery store on the island.
I’ve already written quite extensively on the four best poke places to go to on Oahu, so check out this blog post if you’re interested.
Punaluu Bake Shop Bread
This item may be a little harder to find, but trust me, these loaves of heavenly dough are worth it. Baked at the southern-most tip of the United States on the Big Island of Hawaii, the Punaluu Bake Shop sells sweet bread in a variety of my flavors – my favorites being traditional, guava, and taro. If you are on any island other than the Big Island, check the local Costco, or, if you are on Oahu or Kauai, check the Island Country Market.
Poi in Some Form
I’m not really a fan of the sticky gooey form of taro known as poi. But if you bake it into bread or even mochi donut form, I’m about it.
The most famous places to get malasadas, a type of Portuguese donut, in Hawaii is either at Leonard’s Bakery or Pipeline Bakeshop & Creamery (Check out this post, where I compare the two bakeries – all we decide a winner?). These treats are definitely a local favorite worth trying. I would recommend the original, the cinnamon sugar, or, if you are feeling a bit adventurous, the li hing mui one.
Manapua are meat-filled steamed buns. Heavily influenced by the Chinese dish cha siu bao, the local manapua dish has incorporated a bit of Hawaiian flavor as well.
Giovanni’s Shrimp Truck (Oahu-specific)
Many lists will tell you any North Shore shrimp truck will do. That is not the case. You must go to Giovanni’s (I promise this is not a sponsored post lol). My go-to is always the garlic shrimp – and I recommend that for everyone. For those of you who are going to walk up to the shrimp truck and order the extra spicy shrimp to seem extra macho, don’t do it. I have never met a single person who could tolerate the spicy shrimp. But we all know that’ll make you want to order it more. Don’t say I didn’t warn you.
Haupia in Some Form
Haupia is a coconut-pineapple pudding dessert that you definitely need to try. Ted’s Bakery has some in pie-form for ya, ready to go!
I’ve noticed that on the mainland (also known as the continental United States), many ice cream places are trying to pass off their version of the dole whip. But nothing will compare to the original dole whip of the Dole Plantation of Oahu.
Pro Tip: if you have a local friend, have them come with you. They can get a bit of a discount on this delicious treat for ya.
Loco Moco is composed of a scoop of rice topped with a hamburger patty, a fried egg, and gravy. Don’t knock it until you try it (hopefully at L&L).
This typical luau food is a must-have. If prepared traditionally (which is still sometimes done), the whole pig is actually cooked in a hole in the ground. While it’s quite the extensive process, the result is worth it.
You’re most likely to find huli-huli chicken at a school fundraiser or a random grill on the side of the road. Because the term “huli-huli” was trademarked, you aren’t about to see this teriyaki-infused, constantly-turned, grill-flavored chicken on any menu, so keep your eyes peeled for those alternative options.
Just about everyone else on the entirety of the internet will tell you go to go to Matsumoto’s Shave Ice. However, as I mentioned in a previous post, I think that place is a tourist trap. The shave ice there is a little too sweet even for my taste – and I have a serious sweet tooth. Instead I recommend Island Shave Ice and Creamery, because they use all-natural, reasonably-sweet flavors.
Pro Tip: It is shave ice. Not shaved ice. If you are going to go around calling it shaved ice, you better get used to iced cream too. Any place that says shaved ice isn’t making it right.
I just recently came to realize that saimin is a local dish. It’s kind of like a combo between Japanese ramen, Chinese mein, and Filipino pancit. And surprisingly this combo works quite well.
Li Hing Mui
Li Hing Mui is kind of like a sweet, spicy, sour plum powder. You put it on shave ice, malasadas, and fresh or dried fruit. Honestly, you have to try it to understand how good it is.
To get a whole guava, you’ll have to go to either a local farmers market or a Foodland (a local grocery store). Usually, you’ll get to buy some pink guava, but on occasion you may come across some white guava as well.
Mochi with and without ice cream
I found out that many mainlanders think that mochi is mochi ice cream. In other words, the ice cream is a part of the mochi. No, that is not the case. There is mochi without ice cream, and it is bomb. You can easily buy some at Foodland. But if you are committed to your mochi ice cream, Bubbies is a great place to get some (and in tons of flavors too!)
Homemade Butter Mochi
You have to have some local connections to get this one, but there is a third kind of mochi that’s absolutely fantastic. Butter mochi. And it’s best if it’s homemade. I’ve tried buying it at local grocery stores or farmers markets, but it’s just not the same cake-y, butter-y flavor.
As mentioned in a previous post on the local dialect in Hawaii, lilikoi means passion fruit. And you can’t leave Hawaii without getting something lilikoi-flavored. Lilikoi shave ice, lilikoi mochi ice cream, lilikoi cheese cake, or if you go to fancy restaurants, sometimes they’ll add lilikoi sauces to their dishes.
Honolulu Cookie Company’s Fruit-Flavored Cookies
Yes, I know, fruit-flavored cookies sound odd. But trust me on this one. Where else are you going to be able to try pineapple, guava, or mango cookies? And they also make a great souvenir to take home.
But What If I’m Not Coming to Hawaii Any Time Soon? How Can I Try These Hawaii Food Bucket List at Home?
Want to try some of these foods while you’re at home? I HIGHLY recommend purchasing Maui local, Alana Kysar’s cookbook, Aloha Kitchen. In it, Kysar documents all of the recipes that Hawaii locals love! Written by one Hawaii local, and recommended by another – how much better could this Hawaii cookbook get?
Guess what?! Because you enjoyed this post so much, I decided to make a PART 2 of the Hawaii Food Bucket List!!
Do you have any more items to add to this Hawaii Food Bucket List? Write them below in the comments!
Did you like reading this? Pin it for later!
Disclosure: I may use referral links in this post, and I might make a commission on my recommendations at no extra cost to you.